Introduction:
The Intriguing Question of Time and Eternity
Human existence is
intrinsically tied to the relentless march of time. Lives are meticulously
measured by clocks and calendars, segmented into seconds, minutes, and years.
Yet, beneath this temporal framework, a profound intuition often stirs within
the human spirit: a sense that existence transcends the fleeting moments,
hinting at a deeper, more enduring reality. This yearning for something beyond
the temporal intensifies particularly when contemplating the mystery of life
after physical death. A fundamental question arises: what happens to our
perception and experience of time when our earthly journey concludes?
This contemplation leads
to an intriguing theological and philosophical inquiry: if Christian faith
posits that existence after physical death transitions into a state "out
of time," or into a profoundly different relationship with time, does it
logically follow that humanity is, in some profound and perhaps hidden sense,
already existing in that "out of time" state right now? This question
invites a deep exploration into the very nature of God, the essence of
humanity, and the multi-layered reality that constitutes creation. This
reflection will embark on a journey to explore this captivating question,
examining the classical Christian understanding of God's eternity, the inherent
temporality of human existence, the transformative power of "eternal life"
as a present reality, and how humanity's fallen condition interacts with these
profound truths. The exploration will reveal that while the full, unhindered
"out of time" existence awaits, a significant participation in
eternity is indeed available, here and now, through a relationship with Jesus
Christ.
Part
1: Understanding God's Eternity – Our Blueprint for "Out of Time"
God as the Creator of
Time
Christian theology
fundamentally asserts that God is not bound by time but is its sovereign
creator. Time, alongside space and matter, came into existence through God's
purposeful act of creation, as described in Genesis.1 This means that God
existed prior to time and, consequently, transcends it.3 The concept of God
creating time implies that time is not an independent, eternal entity
co-existing with God, but rather a contingent aspect of His creation.
Augustine, one of the most
influential Christian philosophers, profoundly articulated this concept. He
stated, "It is not in time that you precede times. Otherwise you would not
precede all times. In the sublimity of an eternity which is always in the
present, you are before all things past and transcend all things future,
because they are still to come".3 For
Augustine, God's "years are one Today".3 This means that God does
not experience "before" or "after" in the sequential manner
that humans do; all moments that humanity perceives as past, present, and
future are simultaneously present to God.7 God's existence is described as a
"single, timeless 'present'".9 This atemporal nature of God serves
as the ultimate blueprint for any "out of time" existence,
demonstrating a mode of being that is not subject to chronological succession.
If God exists in an
"eternal present" where all time is simultaneous, a natural
philosophical challenge arises: how can such an atemporal being genuinely
interact with humanity in its temporal reality? Questions emerge regarding how
a timeless God can "hear" prayers from different centuries "at
the same time" 7 or
how a timeless God can "redeem" or "forgive" if these
actions imply a responsive engagement with a temporal event, such as a human
sin or an act of repentance.6 This
appears to contradict the dynamic, relational narratives found throughout the
Bible, where God acts, responds, and even expresses changing emotions or plans.10 This tension highlights a
core debate within Christian theology: reconciling God's perfect, unchanging
nature, often linked to timelessness, with His active, personal involvement in
history. Classical theism often addresses this by distinguishing between God's
internal, atemporal essence and His external, temporal operations. God's
knowledge is not sequential; He knows all things at once.4 His actions in time are
understood as manifestations of His eternal will, not as changes within His
being.5 The personal aspects of
God—His love, forgiveness, and interaction—are considered compatible with
timelessness, not requiring discursive reasoning or temporal decision-making on
His part.12 The philosophical
concepts of "E-simultaneity," which describes God's simultaneous
perception of all time, versus "T-simultaneity," which describes
human sequential perception, help to articulate how this might be possible.8 This understanding
suggests that God's "out of time" existence is not a static, aloof
existence, but a dynamic, all-encompassing presence that embraces all of time
without being limited by it.
Divine Timelessness vs.
Everlastingness: A Continuing Discussion
While classical theology,
rooted in figures like Augustine and Thomas Aquinas, largely affirmed God's
timelessness (atemporality), a more recent and increasingly dominant view among
philosophers is "everlastingness" (sempiternity). This perspective
suggests that God exists in time but without beginning or end,
experiencing temporal succession like humans, but infinitely.3 Proponents of
everlastingness often point to biblical language, such as the Hebrew word
"olam," which connotes long duration, antiquity, and futurity,
suggesting God is everlastingly experiencing rather than timelessly not
experiencing.6 They
also highlight the Incarnation, where God the Son "became flesh"
(John 1:14) and appeared to live as a temporal being, suggesting God's capacity
for temporal existence.13
The ongoing discussion
between timelessness and everlastingness is not merely an abstract
philosophical exercise; it profoundly impacts how God's relationship with
humanity and the possibility of genuine interaction are conceived. If God is
truly timeless, some argue, how can there be genuine prayer, responsive action,
or a "history" that meaningfully unfolds with God?6 The human desire for a
God who "lives His life with us in time" and to whom "yesterday,
today and tomorrow make meaning" 10 often influences the adoption of the
everlasting view. This suggests that the human experience of a dynamic,
personal relationship with God often pushes towards a temporal understanding of
His being, even if classical philosophy argues for a timeless existence. This
reveals that theological frameworks are often shaped by the lived experience of
faith. The initial inquiry, "if we exist out of time when we die then it
stands to reason that we exist currently in that state," implicitly leans
into this relational aspect. If the future state is "out of time,"
and that state is akin to God's eternity, then the question becomes: how can
humanity relate to a timeless God
now? This sets the stage
for exploring human participation in the divine, regardless of whether God is
strictly timeless or everlasting, as both views affirm God's transcendence of
human temporal limitations.
Part
2: Humanity's Temporal Journey and the Promise of Eternity
Humanity's Created State
in Time
From a Christian
perspective, humans are fundamentally temporal beings, created by God to exist
and develop within the framework of time.1 Human lives are inherently marked by
succession, change, and the passage of moments, from birth to death. As one
source articulates, "Humans require time to exist. Potential to be a
different me becomes the actual me only through time. Over time, we change what
we have, such as gaining knowledge or strength. And God can change what we are,
like from a sinner to a saint".1 This highlights
humanity's inherent temporality and developmental nature, emphasizing that
identity and growth are deeply intertwined with the passage of time. Humanity
is composed of beings who
become.
The Nature of the Human
Soul and Post-Death Existence
Christian theology firmly
affirms the immortality of the human soul and its continued, conscious
existence immediately after physical death.16 The soul does not cease to exist when
the body dies.17 The
Apostle Paul's declaration, "To be absent from the body is to be present
with the Lord" (2 Corinthians 5:8), is a cornerstone of this belief.20 It indicates an immediate
transition for believers into God's presence. The spirits of believers who have
died are described as "already in heaven" in an "intermediate
state".20 Biblical examples, such
as Jesus' promise to the thief on the cross ("Today you will be with me in
paradise") and the appearance of Moses and Elijah at the Transfiguration,
further support the idea of a functional, conscious existence immediately after
death.17 This suggests that the
soul, as the immaterial aspect of human being, is not bound by the physical
body's temporal limitations.
If the human soul is
"functional immediately after death" 17 and directly
"present with the Lord" 20, and
if God is often understood as existing in an atemporal "eternal
present" 3, then
this immediate post-death state for the soul could indeed represent a
transition
into an "out of
time" existence. The description of this intermediate state as
"naked" (2 Corinthians 5:1-5) 20 suggests a temporary, perhaps less
fully embodied, but still conscious existence. This implies that the soul's
relationship to time might profoundly change upon separation from the physical
body, moving from a strictly linear experience to one that is, in some sense,
closer to an atemporal perception. This provides a direct theological link to
the initial premise: if death leads to an "out of time" state, it is
because the soul, the core of personal identity, is no longer constrained by
the linear, sequential time of earthly, physical existence. This is not yet
full glorification, but it represents a significant shift in temporal
experience.
Rejection of Soul
Pre-existence and Reincarnation
It is crucial to note that
Christian theology explicitly rejects the idea that human souls existed before
mortal conception (pre-existence) or that they are recycled through
reincarnation.21
Humanity is uniquely created
ex nihilo (out of nothing) by God,
not from a "soul bank".21 The
biblical statement, "It is appointed for men to die once and after this
comes judgment" (Hebrews 9:27), directly refutes the concept of
reincarnation.21
Furthermore, Christian doctrine teaches that the soul is created either at
conception or as part of the physical process of conception, rather than
pre-existing.21
The theological
rejection of pre-existence and reincarnation is foundational because it firmly
grounds human identity and destiny in a singular, linear journey from creation
to judgment and an eternal state. This stands in stark contrast to cyclical
views of time or existence found in other traditions. If human souls
pre-existed, the "out of time" concept would have a very different
meaning, potentially implying a return to a pre-temporal state rather than a
progression into a new, eternal one that is uniquely ours. This establishes
that the "out of time" existence after death is not a return to a
prior state of being, but a new mode of being, a
transformation and glorification, which aligns with the Christian narrative of
salvation and ultimate redemption. It underscores the profound uniqueness and
eternal significance of each individual's temporal life and the choices made within
it.
Part
3: The "Already" of Eternity – Our Present Participation in the
Divine
Eternal Life as a
Present Reality
Herein lies a profound
answer to the initial question. "Eternal life" in Christian theology
is not merely an endless duration after death; it is fundamentally a
qualitative, intimate, and transformative relationship with God that begins now
for those who believe.2 Jesus
Himself defines eternal life in relational terms: "Now this is eternal
life: that they may know You, the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom You
have sent" (John 17:3).2
Furthermore, John 5:24 powerfully declares, "Truly, truly, I tell you,
whoever hears My word and believes Him who sent Me has eternal life and will
not come under judgment. Indeed, he has crossed over from death to life".23 These passages emphasize
that eternal life is a present possession, a spiritual reality that commences
at the moment of faith, not merely a distant future hope.
If God exists in an
"eternal present" where all moments are simultaneously before Him 3, and if "eternal
life" is defined as knowing God intimately
now 2, then this
"knowing" implies a profound participation in God's very nature. If
God's nature is atemporal, then knowing Him intimately could mean, in some
profound sense, participating in His atemporal reality even while physically
situated in time. This is not about literally escaping time's flow, but about
experiencing a dimension of reality that transcends it, a spiritual connection
to the timeless. This provides a direct and affirmative response to the core
inquiry. Current "eternal life" is indeed a qualitative participation
in God's timelessness. It is not that humanity is fully "out of time"
in its physical existence, but that it is
connected to the timeless God in
a way that allows for the experience of aspects of eternity here and now. This
present experience is a "foretaste" of the full reality to come, a
spiritual reality that interacts with and informs temporal existence.
Union with Christ and
the Indwelling of the Holy Spirit
This present participation
in eternal life, and thus in God's eternal nature, is made possible and facilitated
by the doctrines of "union with Christ" and the "indwelling of
the Holy Spirit".25
Believers are promised that through Christ's divine power and precious
promises, they "may participate in the divine nature" (2 Peter 1:4).25 The Apostle Paul
powerfully states, "I have been crucified with Christ and I no longer
live, but Christ lives in me. The life I now live in the body, I live by faith
in the Son of God, who loved me and gave Himself up for me" (Galatians
2:20).23 Furthermore, the Holy
Spirit takes "permanent residence in the body of a believer" 28 at the moment of
conversion, giving the believer "the life of God, eternal life, which is
really His very nature".28 This
indwelling is foundational to Christian life and assurance.29
The Holy Spirit, being the
third Person of the Trinity, is inherently divine and thus atemporal. His
indwelling in believers 28 means
that the timeless God is actively, intimately, and permanently present
within temporal human beings.
This presence is not merely abstract but profoundly transformative, enabling
"victory over sin now already, in the present" 25 and renewing the inner
self "day by day".31 This
dynamic suggests that the Holy Spirit acts as a living conduit, allowing
temporal beings to tap into and experience the "eternal now" of God,
infusing temporal reality with divine presence and power. This provides a
concrete theological mechanism for how humans can participate in eternity
now. The Spirit's presence
allows for a "spiritual transformation" 32 that aligns desires,
priorities, and very being with God's eternal nature, even while physical
bodies remain subject to time and decay. This is not about literally leaving
time, but about infusing experience
in time with the reality
of eternity. It is a profound spiritual reality that transcends, yet interacts
with, chronological existence.
The Christian Experience
of Time and Eternity in Daily Life
This present reality of
eternal life transforms the subjective experience of time, moving it from a
"mindless refrain" or a source of "dread" to one imbued
with purpose, rhythm, and direction.33
Paul's writings speak to this transformation: "The new life in Christ
blasts time apart, end to end, right through the centre of every moment... time
is straightened out like a highway from past to future so that the events of
history and each life lead on to God instead of death. And each moment is
opened up to the eternal in the offer of prayer and contemplation".33 Even as the "outer
self is wasting away," the "inner self is being renewed day by
day".31 This inner renewal is a
tangible sign of present participation in eternity.
If the "inner self is
being renewed day by day" 31 and
individuals can experience "the eternal in the offer of prayer and
contemplation" 33, then
the subjective experience of the "present moment" can be
qualitatively different from a mere fleeting point on a linear timeline. It
becomes a point of intersection with the eternal, a space where the divine
presence is directly encountered. This suggests a form of "Christian
mysticism" 34 where
the transformative presence of God 34
reshapes perception and engagement with time, making the eternal accessible in
the here and now. This means that while physically in time, spiritual reality
can be "hidden with Christ in God" 26, allowing for a present
experience of eternity. This is not about being literally "out of
time" in a physical sense, but about consciousness and spiritual being
operating on a different, eternal plane, even now. It signifies that the
"present" is not just a temporal slice but a gateway to the timeless.
Part
4: Navigating the Paradox – Fallenness, Free Will, and the "Not Yet"
The Impact of the Fall
and Original Sin on our Temporal Existence
While humanity possesses a
present connection to eternity, its current experience is profoundly shaped by
the Fall. Adam's act of disobedience introduced sin and death, profoundly
altering not only human nature but also the entire cosmos.35 This is often referred to
as the "cosmic fall," where creation itself became subjected to
futility.39 Sin is understood as far
more than just individual bad deeds; it is a fundamental "state of
alienation from God and rebellion against Him," a "corruption of
human nature" that distorts desires and motives.32 Romans 5:12-19 is a key
passage, explaining that "through one man sin entered the world, and death
through sin, and so death spread to all men, because all sinned".43 This inherited condition
resulted in spiritual separation from God, physical mortality, psychological
shame and fear, and cosmological consequences, including creation's
"bondage to decay".36
If creation was originally
declared "very good" by God (Genesis 1:31) and God is timeless, then
the Fall introduced a fundamental "temporal distortion" or
"decay" (φθορά) 36 into
what was intended to reflect God's eternal order. This "bondage to
decay" (Romans 8:20-22) 36 means
that the human experience of time is now inherently linked to suffering,
transience, and the "seeming indifference of nature to personality".49 This is why time, for
many, is experienced as "dread and the bringer of death," a measure
of "lost opportunity and failed effort".33 This "temporal
distortion" explains why humanity does not
feel fully "out of
time" now, despite its spiritual connection to eternity. Physical and
psychological being remains deeply embedded in a fallen, decaying temporal
reality. The "groaning of creation" (Romans 8:19-22) 36 is a direct consequence
of this fallen state, a longing for liberation that underscores the "not
yet" aspect of redemption.
Free Will and Divine
Foreknowledge/Atemporal Existence
The tension between God's
perfect omniscience (His knowledge of all future events) and genuine human free
will is a long-standing philosophical and theological problem.7 If God is atemporal and
perceives all events simultaneously (E-simultaneity), then from His
perspective, future events appear "inevitable," which could logically
seem to strip humans of their free will.7 However, Christian philosophers like
Augustine and Aquinas have consistently argued that God's foreknowledge does
not
cause actions but rather sees
them as eternally present, thus maintaining compatibility with human free will.8 God's will "intends
toward one alternative rather than another and does so freely" 12, without compelling human
choices.
If God's knowledge is
timeless and complete, encompassing all choices 10, how can choices be truly
free and morally responsible? Yet, Christian theology insists on human
accountability for sin.52 The
resolution often involves distinguishing God's knowledge from His causation. He
knows what humanity
will freely choose, without
Himself compelling the choice.12 This
implies that even within an "out of time" divine perspective, human
temporal freedom is preserved and remains meaningful. This means that a future
"out of time" existence, even if it involves a fixed nature (as some
traditions suggest for those in hell 54),
does not negate the freedom exercised in the temporal life that
led to that state. The
choices made in time have eternal consequences, and God's atemporal
knowledge encompasses these choices without undermining their genuine freedom
and moral imputability. This reinforces the profound significance of the
temporal journey and the choices made within it.
The "Not Yet"
of Full Glorification
While eternal life is a
present reality for believers, its ultimate fullness, including the
resurrection of the body and the complete liberation of creation from the
effects of sin, is a future hope, an eschatological "not yet".36 The Apostle Paul speaks
of creation "eagerly longing for the revelation of God’s children"
and its eventual liberation from "bondage to corruption" (Romans
8:19-22).36 This "groaning"
is vividly described as "childbirth pains" for a new age 42, signifying a painful but
hopeful anticipation of renewal. Believers, too, are "saved, but not
wholly glorified yet" 42; they
"have yet to come into our inheritance."
The "already but not
yet" tension (eternal life now, full glorification later) 24 is not a contradiction
but a dynamic and purposeful reality within Christian theology. It means that
current "out of time" participation is partial, a down payment, a
spiritual reality that prompts believers to live in a way that reflects their
future glory. This "hope" 24
provides profound comfort in suffering and motivates ethical living,
responsible stewardship of creation, and evangelism.42 It ensures that temporal
existence is not pointless but purposeful. This tension explains why humanity
still experiences time's limitations, the effects of the Fall, and the ongoing
struggle with sin. It means that while connected to eternity, the journey
in time is still vital and
consequential. Actions in this temporal realm have eternal significance,
shaping character and participation in the future, fully "out of
time" reality of the new heavens and new earth.
Conclusion:
Living Eternally, Here and Now
To return to the initial
question: If humanity exists "out of time" when it dies, does it
stand to reason that it exists currently in that state? The answer, from a
philosophical Christian perspective, is a resounding yes,
though with crucial theological nuance. This is not a literal, physical
timelessness in present bodies, but a profound spiritual and relational
connection to God's eternal nature.
God, as the timeless
Creator, is the ultimate "out of time" being, existing in an
"eternal present" where all moments are simultaneously known to Him.
Through faith in Jesus Christ, humanity receives "eternal life" as a
present reality—an intimate, qualitative knowing of God, enabled and sustained
by the indwelling Holy Spirit.2 This
union allows for tapping into God's atemporal reality, experiencing a dimension
of eternity even while navigating temporal lives. However, the full "out
of time" existence, completely free from the effects of the Fall (decay,
suffering, the limitations of current bodies), awaits future glorification and
the new creation. The present experience is a "foretaste," a
"hidden life" with Christ, lived in the tension of the "already
and not yet".24
Understanding this present
connection to eternity imbues temporal lives with profound meaning. Every
moment, every choice, every act of love or service, is not merely fleeting but
resonates with eternal significance.24 It
shapes true identity, which is discovered in relation to the Creator and
anchored in Christ.55 The
groaning of creation and humanity's own inevitable sufferings in time are real,
painful realities. Yet, Paul assures that they are "light and momentary
afflictions" producing an "eternal glory that is far beyond
comparison" (2 Corinthians 4:16-18).24 Hope is anchored not just in a future
escape, but in the "not yet" of full redemption that is already at
work within.
Humanity is called to
actively cultivate this present reality of eternal life through prayer,
contemplation, and living in submission to the indwelling Spirit.29 This is not an ascetic
withdrawal from the world, but a spiritual transformation that deepens
engagement
in the world, allowing for
the perception of its eternal dimensions.11 The "world" that believers
are warned not to love (1 John 2:15-17) is not God's good material creation,
but the "system of rebellion against God".57 Participation in eternity
means aligning affections with God's purposes, rejecting the fleeting and
ultimately disappointing desires of a fallen, temporal system.
Therefore, humanity should
not be enslaved by the relentless tick-tock of the clock, nor by the anxieties
of a passing world. Instead, it is called to live with a vibrant awareness of
the eternal dimension that is already profoundly ours in Christ Jesus. Let
lives be a living testament to the "newness of life" 23 possessed, a life that is
"hidden with Christ in God" 26, even as it walks through this
temporal world. This is the philosophical Christian's call: to think deeply
about these profound truths, to believe boldly in the reality of God's eternal
presence, and to live fully in the dynamic intersection of time and eternity,
until that glorious day when "time shall be no more" (Revelation
10:6) and the full, unhindered revelation of God's glory is experienced.
No comments:
Post a Comment